Sunday 18 October 2009

Background books review

Liber Chaotica Collection

Visually very good, clever and a well thought through and conceived piece….though not the easiest of reads due to the subject matter at hand. Wonderful insights into the Chaos Gods (with some bleed over into 40K), as well as the crafty addition of Undivided….plus the whole ‘writer falling into madness due to subject matter’ was an inspire idea….but as I said before, made it challenging and difficult to read.

7/10

Horus Heresy Art Books (1-4)

Excellent initial background books to the heresy from a mostly Imperial based perspective. Covers most of the well known and pivotal points with pretty pictures too….however, it feels incomplete with glaring things omitted and an ending that seemed very rushed, like other parts of it that delved deeply into the events….could easily have continued on for another edition or two.

8/10

The Sabbat Worlds Crusade – Dan Abnett

As with all background books, it wins on visual aspects but lacks any real narrative and feels very bitty…..the story behind the Sabbat Worlds Crusade is not exempt from that either. It’s good to read more about what’s going on in the cluster besides what the Ghosts are up to, but it’s seemed very ‘all over the place’.

6/10

Xenology – Si Spurrier

Best of the 40K background book I’ve read so far from BL (The Anphelion Project from Imperial Armour holds the top spot). Good mix of storyline and background with a small array of interesting characters with impressive characterisation despite the limited air-time they get….and very Imperialistic with its contradiction. Plus coming from a biological background, the anatomy pictures were particularly of interest to me, despite the Tau having toes instead of some kind of hoof like structure that the figures have.

8.5/1

The Inquisition

A big let down really. High expectations of what may be revealed through a book based on the Ordos but little follow through for the reader.

Brief descriptions were too brief making it feel like a ‘Dummies guide to the Inquisition’ rather than a background book for at least the vaguely informed or an in-depth encyclopaedia. Very little new was mentioned of revealed and felt a little cobbled together.

4/10

The Imperial Infantryman’s Uplifting Primer (1st and Damocles edition)

Brilliant! Pure, unadulterated garbage of the first order that is a giggle from start to finish and a book you have to read twice (once to read the book and once to read all the ‘inspirational’ sayings at the bottom of each page. Utter Imperial propaganda in its more concentrated form that it makes you wonder how and why the Guard swallow that much hogwash! Wonderful!

Great extras in the Damocles edition and some marvellous little contradictions with the Munitorium Manual

10/10

Imperial Munitorium Manual – Graham McNiell

A companion piece to the Primer (for you will be shot if you can’t present this document when asked) but not quite as delightful, but a lot more technical in nature. Great insights into how a Guard army fights though I’d have liked more examples of variety rather than just one case study of a ‘standard’ but I understand the reasons behind it. Though little amendments and other examples at the bottoms of some of the pages was a lovely edition to the main body of the text.

9/10

Titanicus Review

Now, I have to admit that when I first heard the rumours about Dan Abnett writing a Titan based book, I can’t say that I was all aflutter like the vast majority of people were when they heard that exact same news, but I wasn’t all doom and gloom about it either. In truth, I was fairly non-plused and just generally pretty much forgot about the news until Titanicus was officially announced to us all…..and even then I still wasn’t turning hand springs either.

Why was I not beside myself over the thought of a Titan based book written by Dan Abnett? Simple really, I had little or no thoughts or feelings on the Titan Legions themselves, having never really delved all that much into the Legions in any real way. True I knew what they were and most of the different classes (Forge World did help a lot and I so so so so so want a Warhound or two), how they functioned and all the usual, surface and anatomical stuff, but I’d never really gone into their background. And yes, I’d come across some books with Titans in them such as Storm of Iron, Dark Disciple and, of course there’s the Cruor Vult, but these were just side characters in a bigger story that focused on the more ‘normal’ branches of the Imperium…..so weren’t all that representative of the Titan Legions themselves…..though that’s not to say I’m panning anyone else’s take on Titans either.

So overall, I was generally lacking in enthusiasm for Titanicus as its release drew near……thought that’s not to say I didn’t intend to read it in time, if/when I ever got to the bottom of my ‘to be read’ pile and once it was in paperback. However, through unforeseen circumstances that caught me completely by surprise, I found myself in possession of a copy that I hadn’t expected to procure (don’t ask) so I thought ‘What the hell!’ and decided I should at least read it at the first opportune moment, but of course, Cain came first.

Needless to say…..I’m glad that I got the chance to read it now rather than kicking myself stupid over waiting at least a year for the paperback copy (which I feel will happen with The Killing Ground….and I’m not a glutton for punishment either with waiting for two).

Honestly, I’m not sure that I can praise this book enough…..thought that’s not to say it was perfect either.

Negative stuff first.

I have to admit that, especially with Mr. Abnett’s Imperial Guard based books, I find them a little jumpy and disjointed, mainly because his books have such a wide character base, who are all experiencing things at the same time in different places and so need to be covered during the course of the book itself, which necessitates the need to cut from one scene to another group elsewhere, even though their actions can and do have ramifications on other parts of the overall story. With means, on a personal level, there were sections that I read simply so I could get back to the story arcs that I was enjoying the most (which isn’t as bad as it sounds and I liked all of the story arcs, I just liked some more than others). I found this happened with Titanicus, as there were technically a sack load of characters that were covered over the course of the book itself.

However, this large character base is also what I love about Mr. Abnett’s work. Everyone fits into the world and adds an extra depth and richness that has been created, regardless on whether or not that have a bigger part to play in the main storyline….because sometimes characters that are introduced that do little or nothing to further the plot but give glimpse into the other side of Imperial life, to see those who aren’t soldiers and how they live and cope with what’s going on around them…….which, if memory serves, is something he said he liked to do with the Ravenor trilogy.

So characters like Zink, the ex-moderati turned gardener and Zember, the toy maker with his tin titans were such wonderful characters within this story because of the perspectives they gave, what it’s like on not quite on the ground. Looking at what was happening through the eyes of a business man and someone who doesn’t really know what was going on but felt it in his bones (no pun intended)….and I found I had a lot of empathy for these characters because they were victims of circumstance and, with the exception of Zink, or at least what he once was, relatively normal characters.

This is something that was somewhat shadowed with Cally and the Activated Twenty-six. Normal people put into extraordinary situations and being left to basically sink or swim, although I think they had more of an impact on the storyline than the above characters did, but once again, they were people that could be related too on a personal level because they weren’t career soldiers.

I must admit that I was surprised by the Titan Legions themselves. They weren’t as I expected of them, all mechanical, clean and efficient, like their ties to the Mechanicus made me think might happen. In fact I thought they’d be quite snobby too, a bit like the Imperial Navy are. But the camaraderie and loyalty that the Titan crews had for each other and their Legio was highly commendable to say the least. I enjoyed the banter between Moderati Tarses and the bridge crew on Dominatus Victrix and there was a great sense of care given off from the Titan crews for themselves, their crews and the Titans themselves, who I saw as characters in themselves as the book progressed. Despite the fact they never really spoke, a sense of sentience was given to the individual Titans through it all, which was quite creepy but well worth it. But I can’t say I had any love for the Executors though…..they seem too slimy to me, eager to please but it seems only to be lip-service to keep people happy since they answer to their Legio and no one else, despite being liaisons.

What also impressed me was what was done with Gearhart (though seeing all the dead Princeps from the past was a little at odds with everything, in my opinion), and the thought of loosing my mind to a Titan doesn’t make me feel any more comfortable than he felt, especially since we, as reader were pretty much privy to what was going on inside his head, and it felt like an argument I’ve had with myself on a number of occasions over the uncomfortable feeling of losing my mind to some outside influence…..or mainly just me fretting over the thought of getting old and getting some sort of neurological disease that robs me of my mind.

And I have to also admit that I’ve grown somewhat less hard-hearted about all the members of the Adeptus Mechanicus though the use of some of the more less exposed members via the Analyticae and the Enginseers. Those that are a little bit more human that the Magos that seem to get all the airtime. However, there were individuals that seemed to embody the exact reasons why I hate the Mechanicus too, for their greedy, back-stabbing ways.

And the Legio’s Skitarii…….YIKES! Nothing like I’d image them to be, and definitely not like the skitarii I’ve come across that are linked to the Mechanicus.

The pace of the book was perfect and I was sucked into what was going on from the very beginning with Gorland and his men, and the usual range of emotions was running high with what went on in various story arcs and characters, and needless to say there was a few tears by the end of the book over what had happened.

And there was a truly jaw-dropping moment with the sheer audacity of what was unsuspectedly dropped into our laps right in the middle of the book when things already had me on the very edge of my seat. And what was ever more flabbergasting was that there was a very real possibility that what had been discovered was true and could have spelt the end of everything, not just the battle for Orestes…..wasn’t sure how this one was going to play out at all, so that aided in the page-turning-fist-in-my-mouth-reading-into-the-early-hoursness of the book too (and why I finished it so quickly).

But, as always, there were questions that were left unanswered, albeit pretty minor ones that have simply piqued my curiosity over the smaller picture rather than being pivotal to the bigger picture.

Questions such as: Did Golla and Iconis get together? What happened to Gentrian? What happened to the Princeps of the Teratos Titanicus? Does he even have a name? Why was Stefan Stemstag such a burke? Why oh why did Koder drive that truck? What happened to the other, blind and deaf engineseer that Varco and his mob lost through self-presevation?

Favourite Character(s): Engineseer Koder, Golla Uldana, Moderati Tarses, Adept Feist
Favourite Titan: Morbius Sire

All in all…I have to give Titanicus 9.8 out of 10……almost a ‘Malleus’ perfect 10, but not quite.

Tales of Heresy review

Here's my thoughts on the Horus Heresy Anthology 'Tales of Heresy'

Enjoy.

The Skull Harvest – As per usual, I enjoy this story, though not as much as I enjoyed the short in Planet Kill, whose name eludes me right now. Can’t really say why that is, possibly something to do with how that one ended…..but The Skull Harvest was clearly yet another staging point towards the inevitable Battle Royale that will be had at the end of the Ultramarines series. What makes it most interesting is what the Newborn will do at the end as there hints that parts of Uriel’s personality may be hard to stomp out of him. But over all, as solid as any story I’ve read by Mr. McNeill on this subject matter and makes me thirsty for more.

Gauntlet Run – Now I can’t deny that I went into this story with some expectation with it being a tie-in to Sons of Dorn…..and I think that expectation may have been a little too high. That’s not to say that I didn’t enjoy the story, I thought it was ok, but I felt the pacing was all wrong. I felt it was a bit slow, which didn’t feel right in a story about a high speed chase. I didn’t quite feel the rush of race as I read the story so I felt a little flat. However, I liked what happened at the end. It’s not often that sort of thing happens, so it was a nice surprise. So I’m a little hesitant of Sons of Dorn now, but I’ll still buy it anyway to see what the real deal is like.

Renegades – The title confused me somewhat when I started reading the story, making me wonder who the title was referring too. But as things went on, I found myself being a little crest-fallen when what happened happened because; quite simply I wanted them to resist. Which is both good and not quite as good because a) good characters that give you some sort of emotion response through their actions (I’m a character driven gal, always have been, always will be) b) it was a shade unexpected and since I kinda liked the character is was a bit of a knife in the gut. Though I would have liked a little more inner turmoil over the discussions, but that could be a book in itself. Wouldn’t be adverse to more though.

Honour Amongst Fiends – I really enjoyed this one. Nice little covert op story that it was. Plus what I really enjoyed is the neat little glimpse into the fact that Chaos doesn’t make everything all better. I do so love it when the Chaos Gods are actually being quite nasty rather than your basic ‘Crush, kill, destroy’ and they’re wonderfully insidious here that almost made me point and laugh at Scaevolla for being a mug…..except for the fact that he completed his mission which made me hate him when I could have almost felt sorry for him being nothing more than a pawn.

Fires Of War – After Gauntlet Run I was a shade apprehensive with another tie-in, but rather than let one things be the judge of all similar, I ploughed right on in. Now I’ have to admit that I’m one of the people that has wanted to have a Salamanders books for a while now, though I may not have been shouting it from the rooftops, so I intrigued me to see how Mr. Kyme has been commanding them. And I’m impressed. I liked the conflict that Kadai felt over his decision, I liked that Dak’ir was a good guy but most of all I liked the fact that Tsu’gan was a stuck-up git! Nice twist at the end too which made me think of the phrase ‘No one suspects the butterfly’ because I was surprised by what happened. After this, I’m definitely looking forward to Salamander.

The Labyrinth – It took me a few pages to work out exactly who these guys where when I started reading the book, the friendship and camaraderie that the two main characters shaded didn’t make me think of ‘renegades’ until it was mentioned who they were. Which put me in a good mood overall because I like to see Chaos/Renegade Marines not just being mindless, blood thirsty, kill absolutely everyone no matter who they are, butchers. And the concept itself was a great one too, completely unexpected and it made me smile to see such deceit. Could have been more chopping though, but that’s only because we didn’t see what happened. But only a small gripe from my blood-thirsty point of view.

Headhunted – Easily my favourite of the stories. Some ace characters that I really enjoyed reading about….a great mix of clashing personalities and despite everything worked well together. Loved Zeed. There was a time when I thought the mix of personalities would have actually worked in ‘reality’, but then I remembered that this is fiction and Solarion isn’t a Captain so there’s no real disrespected and I stopped the gripe before it started and just enjoyed characters that weren’t all cut from one mould.

The story was great too, pacy and action packed and there were times when I held my breathe that they might have blown the mission, like with the Squig pit (liked that small detail too and felt quite bad for the Squigs getting eaten….until lunch bit back). The only thing that gave me pause was the bit with the mention of the Grey Knights. Although I’d heard that as a spoken rumour, it’s something else to see it written, which I usually take as pretty much being confirmed…but I’m not sure I’ve ever agreed with this rumour, despite the possibilities. Don’t know why I’ve ever agreed with it, but it just doesn’t sit right with me that Chapters have been created from a Grey Knights stock. But that’s just me.

And They Shall Know No Fear – Now I always struggle with Black Templars, no matter who they are, what they’re doing or who writes them, I struggle as I have an instant disliked for them for no reason other than the fact that they’re Black Templars. So I have to admit that it took me a few goes to get started with this story, purely because of my hatred for Black Templars and not other reason than that. However, by the end I found myself being a little less harsh with them over Reinhart’s final decision, which made me feel that despite everything else, maybe there’s some Black Templars who aren’t just arrogant [insert nasty word]. Nice little twist at the very end too and thanks to Mr. Cox, my dislike of Black Templars has eased off a fraction. Kudos to you sir, it’s a hard thing to do.

Nightfall – This surprised me, not by the fact that it was a Night Lords story, but more due to the fact that it wasn’t written by Mr. Dembski- Bowden. After reading Shadow Knight, I found my hopes rekindled for a good novel featuring Night Lords as I really enjoyed the short story he wrote, so I went into Nightfall using Shadow Knight as a measuring stick…..and I’m glad that Mr. Fehervari and Nightfall lived up to the challenge, despite the fact that the Night Lords weren’t really the main character in the story. But I have to admit, I’m very excited at the fact we’re getting a Night Lords book now from what I’ve read from these two guys. The atmosphere in the story was suitably chilly for the subject matter and it was great to have Raptors out and about and griping and sniping against each other, that and the divide between Astartes (30K born) and Space Marines (not 30K born) without descending into the whole ‘woe is me’ aspect of the Night Lords . Plus I’d love to find out what happens next with this one too.


A fresh start

I've decided to start up my blog again.....but rather than do nothing but bitch, whine and moan about life....I'm going to use it for my BL reviews (and possibly just general reviews of other things too).

Let the word count commence!